Equifax vs Cassini

The tired trope from free market exponents is that private enterprise is agile, efficient, and competent, while government is prodding, incompetent, and wasteful. The argument is that because companies must survive in a competitive environment they are always striving to improve and gain an edge against their competitors. Yet history and recent events seem to indicate otherwise. The best strategy in capitalism seems to be to gain monopoly power and extract rent. While Equifax was busy covering up their malfeasance instead of trying to fix things for everyone they harmed, Cassini ended a brilliantly successful mission to explore Saturn. The contrast couldn’t have been greater if it was staged. The so-called incompetent government has given us moon landings, the internet, and built two Voyager spacecraft that have lasted 40 years and have now exited the Solar system into interstellar space. There is no better run organization than JPL. Each day at NIH, a government facility, I get to interact with effective and competent people who are trying to do good in the world. I think it’s time to update the government is the problem meme.


6 thoughts on “Equifax vs Cassini

  1. I think the prefection of the free market has been proven many times. (eg see SMD theorem or sonnenchein -mantel-debrue). (sonnenchein was presdient of U chicago too. Malliaris of UC with Shelah recently got a prize for some result p=t in PNAS about infinity. Kadanoff, Wilson, and Jack Cowan were also at UC and may still be).
    i had a relative there in music wrote a book ‘meanng and information theory in music’.

    Prominent economists —eg David Friedman (son of milton–the writer), with a PhD in physics, Bryan Caplan at GMU , mercatus center—show it would be better if government were replaced by anarcho-capitalism (if you want a country, military, police, or roads or science don’t ask someone to give you ‘free stuff’ (welfare) just DIY. )
    The whole econ and law depts at GMU and Mercatus ctr show why free markets are best—the people who are in those depts otherwise couldnt have a job so instead we have a govt supported market failure.

    I guess one could say Tyler Cowan of GMU writes good restaurant guides if you can afford them. (i’m doing a PhD in writing restaruant guides—i do it from first principles. start with a stochastic lagrangian.).

    Most reasonable people don’t believe there was any cassini or moon landings. The night sky is created in observatories using technology. Friedman (static) universe Thats just superstition . https://arxiv.org/abs/1309.1019 Rush Limbaugh— a competent news source— also pointed out there was no hurricanes in florida—thats just fake news. (If there was one then mostly likely it was an ‘inside job’ –probably geoengineered by NOAA.)

    perhaps the most succesful govt programs were Trump, Robert Mcnmara and vietnam war.


  2. https://arxiv.org/abs/1308.1019 arxiv shows why NSF funded science is innneficient. they can’t even put in the correct urls. in a free market every url or web site you type in is correct. and watches always have exact if only 2 times a day.
    and because watches like markets are continuous and adjusting –no frictions–adibiatic processes–(none of those ‘quantum jumps’–see schrodinger ‘what is life’) you can adjust them to make sure you are never late.a dollar is always a dollar (robert lucas, rational expectations noble prize from UC) and there’s never involuntary or other unemployment –can’t exist—and you can’t devalue the dollar compared to the euro or yen or reverse and you’ll never find one on the ground.


  3. Us free marketers don’t argue perfection of the free markets just relative performance to the government. We would only argue that the if the government was running Equifax then the problems would be worse than they are now and that if the private sector ran space exploration than the successes would be greater than are now.


  4. It is obvious to any of us who have spent time in government and spent time in the private sector that government runs far more smoothly and efficiently than the vast majority of private-sector organizations. This fact is in spite of the incompetence of the political people at the top (the most incompetent ones come from “successful” businesses). Criticism of government comes from two places: 1) ignorance 2) pathological self-interest.


  5. @kevin Well, I was affected by the OPM breech a few years ago and they immediately addressed the problem and set about rectifying the situation. I still can’t get the link Equifax sent me to work.


  6. Do your examples show efficiency of government in allocating goods and services, or are your examples in the areas that are not mandatory for a functioning economy?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s